Building Exteriors, Building Relationships 228-432-4067 | 601-342-0979

Why do appraisers lowball?

Real estate appraisals play a crucial role in determining the fair market value of a property, influencing various aspects of the buying and selling process. Occasionally, homeowners may find themselves questioning why appraisers seem to undervalue their properties, leading to what is colloquially known as a “lowball” appraisal. In this article, we will explore some common reasons behind appraisers’ valuations that may fall below homeowners’ expectations.

  1. Market Fluctuations:

Real estate markets are dynamic, experiencing fluctuations due to various economic factors. Appraisers rely on recent comparable sales data, and if the market has experienced a decline in property values, it can contribute to lower appraisals. Market conditions play a significant role in shaping the appraiser’s assessment of a property’s value.

  1. Limited Comparable Sales:

The appraisal process heavily relies on comparable sales (comps) – recent sales of similar properties in the vicinity. If there are limited recent sales or a lack of comparable properties in the area, appraisers may face challenges in accurately gauging the property’s value. In such cases, appraisers may err on the side of caution, leading to lower valuations.

  1. Overpricing or Unique Features:

Sometimes, homeowners may overprice their properties, leading to a discrepancy between the listed price and the appraised value. Additionally, if a property has unique features or improvements that differ significantly from the local market norm, appraisers may struggle to find suitable comparables, potentially resulting in a lower valuation.

  1. Deferred Maintenance and Repairs:

The condition of a property is a critical factor in determining its value. Appraisers take into account the level of maintenance and any needed repairs. Properties with deferred maintenance or significant repair issues may receive lower valuations as appraisers consider the cost of bringing the property up to standard.

  1. Incomplete or Inaccurate Information:

Accurate information is crucial for a fair appraisal. If homeowners provide incomplete or inaccurate details about the property, such as omitting recent renovations or upgrades, it can impact the appraiser’s ability to assess its true value. Clear communication and transparency are essential for an accurate valuation.

  1. Economic Downturns and Economic Factors:

During economic downturns or times of financial uncertainty, appraisers may adopt a conservative approach to property valuations. Economic factors, such as high unemployment rates or a decline in consumer confidence, can influence appraisers to be cautious in their assessments, potentially resulting in lower appraisals.

  1. Appraiser’s Lack of Familiarity with the Area:

Local market knowledge is crucial for an accurate appraisal. If the appraiser is unfamiliar with the specific neighborhood or lacks recent experience in the area, they may rely on broader market trends, potentially leading to discrepancies in the valuation compared to the local nuances.

  1. Appraiser Independence and Objectivity:

Appraisers are expected to maintain independence and objectivity in their assessments. They are not influenced by the desires or expectations of the buyer, seller, or lender. In their pursuit of an unbiased valuation, appraisers may arrive at figures that differ from the parties involved in the real estate transaction.


While low appraisals can be frustrating for homeowners, it’s essential to recognize that appraisers follow a standardized and objective approach to property valuation. Understanding the factors that contribute to lower appraisals, such as market fluctuations, limited comparables, and property condition, can help homeowners navigate the appraisal process more effectively. Clear communication, accurate information, and an awareness of local market dynamics can contribute to a more accurate and fair property valuation.

How to find us: